So, we planted a couple cucumbers in the community garden one lovely May day and within weeks, they became our vegetarian overloads.
See, the thing about this pickle recipe is that it calls for teensy cucumbers, specifically the "size of your thumb." You can't buy these from the grocery store, and I've never seen them at a farmer's market. If you want this (and you do want this), you gotta DIY. You will not find 300 of these cucumbers at the same time; you'll have to add them to the crock as they become available. In practice, this means harvesting your cucumbers every 2-3 days.
The Boy Scout was hazy on just how big his parents' pickle crock was, but we (correctly) predicted that one recipe only filled about a third of ours -- and the cucumbers just kept rolling in. It didn't take long before we decided to add half a batch of brine, then another full recipe (if you're keeping count, that's 2.5 total batches of pickles). Also? You come from a family that depends on their garden to feed their many kids? You don't waste anything. We ate Italian summer salads and Greek summer salads and gazpacho and we gave pounds of them away to the neighbors. Six weeks into harvesting, I was praying for those cucumber vines to die already.
The recipe itself requires a lot of time. You cannot skip a day of adding sugar and stirring. You cannot blithely frolic past the brine-drain-dry method that keeps your pickles crisp and teed up for fermentation -- unless you want to flirt with, oh, say botulism. This is serious business: I designed a pickle tracker to make sure we didn't die. (I am inordinately proud of it and may provide a template and semiotic explanation in a separate post.)
Here's the real secret: if you're already going to spend this much time making this recipe, do not deviate from the New York Times spice mix recipe or something just as kick-a**. Nana's just calls for "mixed pickling spice" and it's one of those old skool things where everyone knew what that meant and everyone had their own spin on it. We didn't have Nana's spin, so we researched. You need to invest the same care in your spice mix that you do in the rest of the pickling process. Those dusty, old, overpriced bottles of pickling mix sold at the grocery store ain't gonna cut it.
Also, don't fret about the size of the cucumbers too much. We tossed in some 4-6 inchers just because we were so sick of eating them. They are fine. They just need a little longer in the crock to soak up the pickling brine, and as time goes on, they will shrink/wrinkle more, become a little less crisp, and hollow out in the middle where the seeds were. Otherwise, they taste just like the tiny ones.
Finally, be patient. Adding cucumbers throughout the 19-day period means it's going to take at least one month, probably two, before your batch really shines.
And I promise, it's worth the effort. Our neighbors took care of our cats when we were away for a summer weekend, and we dragooned them into the pickle coddling. We finally dished up a sample for one of them last month, and we nearly made him cuss at their deliciousness. They will make you and your friends and your family happy throughout the fall and holiday feasting season and the cold, gray winter days following -- and give you the needed nudge to do it all over again next summer.
Nana's 19-Day Crock Pickles
prep cucumbers
- 300 small cucumbers (size of your thumb)
- 1 cup coarse pickling salt*
- boiling water
- Scrub cukes well, rinse, and place in crock.* Add salt and boiling water to cover and let stand overnight.
- In the morning, drain crock. DO NOT RINSE cucumbers, but wipe/pat excess salt brine from each one with paper towels (really). Put cukes in crock.
* If you are "small batching" cucumbers, use 1/4 c pickling salt per 2 quarts water.
pickling spice recipe
- 2 tbsp black peppercorns
- 2 tbsp mustard seeds
- 2 tbsp coriander seeds
- 2 tbsp hot red pepper flakes
- 2 tbsp allspice berries
- 2 tbsp cardamom pods, lightly cracked
- 1 tbsp ground mace
- 2 small cinnamon sticks, crushed or broken into pieces
- 25 medium bay leaves, crumbled (fresh is better than dried, if you've got 'em)
- 2 tbsp whole cloves
- 1 tbsp ground ginger
- Combine peppercorns, mustard seeds and coriander seeds in a small dry pan. Place over medium heat and stir until fragrant, being careful not to burn them; keep lid handy in case seeds pop. Crack peppercorns and seeds in mortar and pestle or with the side of a knife on cutting board.
- Combine with other spices, mix. Store in tightly sealed plastic or glass container.
pickling brine and process
- ½ gallon cider vinegar
- 4 tablespoons sugar
- 4 tablespoons salt
- 4 tablespoons dry mustard
- ½ cup whole mixed pickling spice
- 3 pounds sugar
- Add first 5 ingredients to 3-gallon crock (or larger) and stir well. Add cucumbers and place cover on crock.
- Each day for the next 18 days add 1/3 cup sugar – stirring until dissolved; then replace cover.
Pickles may be placed in jars after all sugar has been
added. If you added cucumbers to the brine in batches, wait at least one month after last cucumbers have been added to allow flavor to develop.